Halloween in Early America

An Evening at the Research Desk

Before Trick-or-Treating, Part III

When we left our story, Halloween was already a patchwork of customs, beliefs, amusements, and stories. Some had been preserved by poets, others by collectors of folklore, and still others by families who simply remembered what people used to do.

But those traditions were not destined to remain on one side of the Atlantic.

As people migrated to North America, they carried memories of familiar celebrations with them. Customs might be remembered, adapted, combined with others, or gradually abandoned.

And the Hallowe’en that eventually emerged in America was not simply an unchanged copy of its Old World past.

When we left our story, Halloween was becoming something distinctly American.

Listen to The Kitchen Radio Hour

Put the kettle on and join me in the kitchen.

Part III — Halloween in Early America. An illustrated journey through old customs, newspaper archives, and a changing American Halloween.

Prefer listening? Find The Kitchen Radio Hour on Substack .

Across the Atlantic

Old Traditions in a New World

The history of Halloween in America cannot be explained by a single arrival date or one group of immigrants.

Traditions traveled through different communities, at different times, and under different circumstances. A familiar custom might survive within a family without becoming a widespread public celebration.

That distinction matters when we investigate early American Halloween. Evidence of an old custom being remembered is not necessarily evidence that everyone was practicing it.

The Newspaper Archives

When Halloween Was Already Becoming a Memory

One of the more intriguing discoveries in our research was that nineteenth-century writers were already looking backward at Halloween traditions.

In our research notes, we encountered a New York newspaper discussion from 1822 concerning the disappearance of older customs.

Another New York newspaper account, dated 1852, described old Halloween divinations as practices belonging to an earlier world.

These references deserve careful reading in their original newspaper context. They offer a fascinating glimpse of how writers described the past, but do not by themselves establish how common any particular Halloween practice was across America.

New York newspaper account from 1822 — Long Island Farmer, and Queens County Advertiser An 1822 newspaper reference to changing or disappearing customs.

New York newspaper account from 1852 — The Brooklyn Daily Eagle An 1852 account looking back at older Halloween divinations.

Even before Halloween became the American celebration we recognize today, people were already debating what belonged to the past.

An American Chapter

A Visit to Pennsylvania

From New York’s newspaper pages, our journey takes us to Pennsylvania, a place especially close to my heart.

Pennsylvania’s communities brought together different backgrounds, languages, and inherited customs. Exploring Halloween here requires looking closely at local records rather than assuming that every community celebrated alike.

It is in these smaller details— a newspaper account, a remembered game, a gathering, or a local story— that the larger history begins to take shape.

Historical Pennsylvania town or countryside — Historical Image — Verify Credit Johnstown, Pennsylvania, in the nineteenth century. Historically inspired illustration.

An imagined early American autumn gathering — Historically Inspired Illustration Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, in autumn during the nineteenth century. Historically inspired illustration.

Old Fortunes, New Settings

What Became of the Halloween Games?

In the earlier episodes, we encountered hazelnuts placed in the fire, kale pulled from the garden, and other attempts to discover the identity of a future spouse.

As Halloween customs appeared in American descriptions, familiar fortune-telling amusements remained part of the conversation.

Yet a printed description might preserve an older practice, introduce readers to an unfamiliar custom, or describe something still enjoyed locally.

Determining which is which requires more than a charming illustration or a nostalgic newspaper paragraph.

An old-fashioned Halloween apple game — Historically Inspired Illustration Apple games at an old-fashioned Halloween gathering.

Young people enjoying a Halloween fortune-telling game — Historically Inspired Illustration A Halloween fortune-telling amusement in an American setting.

A Little Assorted Deviltry

The Mischievous Side of Halloween

Halloween’s American story would eventually include a rather mischievous reputation.

Alongside parties and games, accounts of youthful pranks became part of the holiday’s developing identity.

But we should resist the temptation to treat every later Halloween prank as an ancient tradition. The evidence changes over time, and so do the circumstances in which the stories appear.

For now, the important point is that Halloween was changing. The old romantic fortunes had not vanished from the record, but another kind of excitement was beginning to claim attention.

An old-fashioned American Halloween gathering — Historically Inspired Illustration An old-fashioned American Halloween evening.

A mischievous Halloween scene — Historically Inspired Illustration A little Halloween mischief.

Coming in Part IV

Halloween Becomes an American Tradition

Next, we follow the changing celebration further into American history, where Halloween mischief, neighborhood customs, and the rise of trick-or-treating bring new questions to the research desk.

Part IV — Coming soon to The Kitchen Radio Hour.

From the Research Desk